When it comes to choosing the right wood for your acoustic guitar top, there are many factors to consider, including tone, volume, and appearance. Three of the most popular woods used for acoustic guitar tops are cedar, spruce, and mahogany.
Editor’s Note: Deciding which wood is best for your acoustic guitar top can be a daunting task. That’s why we’ve put together this comprehensive guide to help you make the right decision.
After analyzing the sound quality and characteristics of each wood, we have put together this cedar guitar spruce vs mahogany for acoustic guitar top guide to help you make the right decision for your next acoustic guitar.
Key Differences
| Characteristic | Cedar | Spruce | Mahogany |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tone | Warm, mellow | Bright, crisp | Rich, full |
| Volume | Soft | Loud | Medium |
| Appearance | Reddish-brown | Yellowish-white | Dark brown |
Main Article Topics
- The different types of cedar, spruce, and mahogany used for acoustic guitar tops
- The tonal characteristics of each wood
- The volume and projection of each wood
- The appearance of each wood
- The pros and cons of each wood
1. Tonal qualities
The tonal qualities of a guitar top wood are one of the most important factors to consider when choosing a guitar. The type of wood used for the top will have a significant impact on the overall sound of the guitar.
Cedar is a softwood that produces a warm, mellow sound. Cedar tops are often used on classical guitars and other guitars that are played fingerstyle. Spruce is a softwood that produces a bright, crisp sound. Spruce tops are often used on guitars that are played with a pick, such as bluegrass guitars and dreadnought guitars. Mahogany is a hardwood that produces a rich, full sound. Mahogany tops are often used on guitars that are played with a pick or fingerstyle.
The tonal qualities of a guitar top wood are not just a matter of personal preference. The type of wood used for the top will also affect the guitar’s volume, projection, and sustain. Cedar tops are typically softer and produce less volume than spruce or mahogany tops. Spruce tops are typically louder and project more than cedar or mahogany tops. Mahogany tops are typically louder and project more than cedar tops, but less than spruce tops.
The tonal qualities of a guitar top wood are also affected by the thickness of the top. Thicker tops will produce a warmer, mellower sound, while thinner tops will produce a brighter, crisper sound. The thickness of the top will also affect the guitar’s volume and projection.
Ultimately, the best way to choose a guitar top wood is to try out different guitars and see which one sounds best to you. There is no right or wrong answer, and the best wood for you will depend on your personal preferences.
| Wood | Tonal qualities | Volume | Projection |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cedar | Warm, mellow | Soft | Low |
| Spruce | Bright, crisp | Loud | High |
| Mahogany | Rich, full | Medium | Medium |
2. Volume
The volume of an acoustic guitar is an important factor to consider when choosing a guitar. The volume of a guitar is determined by a number of factors, including the size of the body, the type of wood used for the top, and the thickness of the top. Spruce is the loudest of the three woods commonly used for acoustic guitar tops, followed by mahogany and then cedar.
- Body size: The size of the body of an acoustic guitar has a significant impact on the volume of the guitar. Larger bodies produce more volume than smaller bodies.
- Wood type: The type of wood used for the top of an acoustic guitar also has a significant impact on the volume of the guitar. Spruce is the loudest of the three woods commonly used for acoustic guitar tops, followed by mahogany and then cedar.
- Top thickness: The thickness of the top of an acoustic guitar also has an impact on the volume of the guitar. Thinner tops produce more volume than thicker tops.
In general, spruce is the best choice for a loud acoustic guitar. Spruce tops are thin and stiff, which allows them to vibrate more easily and produce more volume. Mahogany and cedar tops are not as loud as spruce tops, but they have other tonal qualities that make them popular choices for acoustic guitars.
Ultimately, the best way to choose an acoustic guitar is to try out different guitars and see which one sounds best to you. There is no right or wrong answer, and the best guitar for you will depend on your personal preferences.
3. Appearance
The appearance of an acoustic guitar top is an important factor to consider when choosing a guitar. The type of wood used for the top will have a significant impact on the overall look of the guitar. Cedar is a reddish-brown wood, spruce is a yellowish-white wood, and mahogany is a dark brown wood.
The appearance of the guitar top is not just a matter of personal preference. The type of wood used for the top will also affect the guitar’s sound. Cedar tops produce a warm, mellow sound, while spruce tops produce a bright, crisp sound. Mahogany tops produce a rich, full sound.
In addition to the sound, the appearance of the guitar top can also affect the guitar’s value. Guitars with rare or exotic woods are often more valuable than guitars with common woods.
Ultimately, the best way to choose an acoustic guitar top is to try out different guitars and see which one looks and sounds best to you. There is no right or wrong answer, and the best guitar for you will depend on your personal preferences.
Here is a table summarizing the appearance, sound, and value of the three most popular woods used for acoustic guitar tops:
| Wood | Appearance | Sound | Value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cedar | Reddish-brown | Warm, mellow | Low |
| Spruce | Yellowish-white | Bright, crisp | Medium |
Mahogany | Dark brown | Rich, full | High |
4. Grain
The grain of the wood is an important factor to consider when choosing an acoustic guitar top. The grain of the wood will affect the appearance, sound, and durability of the guitar.
- Appearance: The grain of the wood will affect the appearance of the guitar. Cedar has a straight grain, which gives it a clean, classic look. Spruce has a slightly wavy grain, which gives it a more rustic look. Mahogany has a more pronounced wavy grain, which gives it a rich, luxurious look.
- Sound: The grain of the wood will also affect the sound of the guitar. Cedar is known for its warm, mellow sound. Spruce is known for its bright, crisp sound. Mahogany is known for its rich, full sound.
- Durability: The grain of the wood will also affect the durability of the guitar. Cedar is a softwood, which makes it more susceptible to dents and scratches. Spruce is a softwood, but it is more durable than cedar. Mahogany is a hardwood, which makes it the most durable of the three woods.
Ultimately, the best way to choose an acoustic guitar top is to try out different guitars and see which one looks, sounds, and feels best to you. However, understanding the different grains of wood can help you narrow down your choices and find the perfect guitar for your needs.
5. Density
The density of the wood is an important factor to consider when choosing an acoustic guitar top. The density of the wood will affect the weight, tone, and volume of the guitar.
Cedar is the least dense of the three woods commonly used for acoustic guitar tops, followed by spruce and then mahogany. Cedar is a softwood, while spruce and mahogany are hardwoods. The density of a wood is measured in pounds per cubic foot (lbs/ft3). Cedar has a density of about 25 lbs/ft3, spruce has a density of about 30 lbs/ft3, and mahogany has a density of about 45 lbs/ft3.
The density of the wood will affect the weight of the guitar. A guitar with a cedar top will be lighter than a guitar with a spruce or mahogany top. The density of the wood will also affect the tone of the guitar. A guitar with a cedar top will have a warmer, mellower sound than a guitar with a spruce or mahogany top. Spruce tops produce a brighter, more articulate sound, while mahogany tops produce a richer, fuller sound.
The density of the wood will also affect the volume of the guitar. A guitar with a cedar top will be quieter than a guitar with a spruce or mahogany top. Spruce tops produce more volume than cedar tops, and mahogany tops produce the most volume of the three.
Ultimately, the best way to choose an acoustic guitar top is to try out different guitars and see which one sounds and feels best to you. However, understanding the density of the wood can help you narrow down your choices and find the perfect guitar for your needs.
Here is a table summarizing the density, weight, tone, and volume of the three most popular woods used for acoustic guitar tops:
| Wood | Density (lbs/ft3) | Weight | Tone | Volume |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cedar | 25 | Light | Warm, mellow | Quiet |
| Spruce | 30 | Medium | Bright, articulate | Loud |
| Mahogany | 45 | Heavy | Rich, full | Very loud |
6. Stiffness
The stiffness of the wood is an important factor to consider when choosing an acoustic guitar top. The stiffness of the wood will affect the guitar’s tone, volume, and sustain.
- Tone: The stiffness of the wood will affect the tone of the guitar. A stiffer wood will produce a brighter, more articulate sound, while a less stiff wood will produce a warmer, mellower sound. Spruce is the stiffest of the three woods commonly used for acoustic guitar tops, followed by mahogany and then cedar. Therefore, spruce tops produce a brighter, more articulate sound, while cedar tops produce a warmer, mellower sound.
- Volume: The stiffness of the wood will also affect the volume of the guitar. A stiffer wood will produce more volume than a less stiff wood. Spruce is the stiffest of the three woods commonly used for acoustic guitar tops, followed by mahogany and then cedar. Therefore, spruce tops produce more volume than cedar tops.
- Sustain: The stiffness of the wood will also affect the sustain of the guitar. A stiffer wood will produce longer sustain than a less stiff wood. Spruce is the stiffest of the three woods commonly used for acoustic guitar tops, followed by mahogany and then cedar. Therefore, spruce tops produce longer sustain than cedar tops.
Ultimately, the best way to choose an acoustic guitar top is to try out different guitars and see which one sounds and feels best to you. However, understanding the stiffness of the wood can help you narrow down your choices and find the perfect guitar for your needs.
7. Responsiveness
Responsiveness refers to how quickly and easily a guitar top vibrates when it is strummed or picked. A more responsive top will produce a louder and more resonant sound. Cedar is the most responsive of the three woods commonly used for acoustic guitar tops, followed by spruce and then mahogany.
- Tonal qualities: The responsiveness of a guitar top will affect its tonal qualities. A more responsive top will produce a brighter, more articulate sound, while a less responsive top will produce a warmer, mellower sound. Cedar tops are known for their warm, mellow sound, while spruce tops are known for their bright, crisp sound. Mahogany tops produce a rich, full sound that is somewhere in between cedar and spruce.
- Volume: The responsiveness of a guitar top will also affect its volume. A more responsive top will produce more volume than a less responsive top. Cedar tops are not as loud as spruce tops, but they are louder than mahogany tops. Mahogany tops produce the least volume of the three.
- Sustain: The responsiveness of a guitar top will also affect its sustain. A more responsive top will produce longer sustain than a less responsive top. Cedar tops have a shorter sustain than spruce tops, but a longer sustain than mahogany tops.
Ultimately, the best way to choose an acoustic guitar top is to try out different guitars and see which one sounds and feels best to you. However, understanding the responsiveness of the wood can help you narrow down your choices and find the perfect guitar for your needs.
8. Durability
Durability is an important factor to consider when choosing an acoustic guitar top. The durability of the wood will affect the guitar’s lifespan and resistance to wear and tear.
- Resistance to scratches and dents: Mahogany is the most resistant to scratches and dents of the three woods commonly used for acoustic guitar tops, followed by spruce and then cedar. This is because mahogany is a hardwood, while spruce and cedar are softwoods. Hardwoods are denser and more durable than softwoods.
- Resistance to moisture: Mahogany is also more resistant to moisture than spruce and cedar. This is because mahogany contains natural oils that help to repel water. Spruce and cedar are more susceptible to moisture damage, which can cause the wood to warp or crack.
- Resistance to fading: Mahogany is also more resistant to fading than spruce and cedar. This is because mahogany contains pigments that help to protect the wood from the sun’s UV rays. Spruce and cedar are more susceptible to fading, which can cause the wood to lose its color over time.
Ultimately, the best way to choose an acoustic guitar top is to try out different guitars and see which one sounds and feels best to you. However, understanding the durability of the wood can help you narrow down your choices and find the perfect guitar for your needs.
9. Cost
When choosing an acoustic guitar top, the cost of the wood is an important factor to consider. The cost of the wood will vary depending on the type of wood, the grade of the wood, and the availability of the wood. Cedar is the least expensive of the three woods commonly used for acoustic guitar tops, followed by spruce and then mahogany.
- Availability: Cedar is a softwood that is found in many parts of the world. Spruce is also a softwood, but it is not as common as cedar. Mahogany is a hardwood that is found in tropical regions. The availability of the wood will affect the cost of the wood.
- Grade: The grade of the wood will also affect the cost of the wood. The grade of the wood is determined by the quality of the wood. Clear wood is free of knots and other defects. Select wood has a few small knots and other defects. Standard wood has more knots and other defects. The higher the grade of the wood, the more expensive the wood will be.
- Type: The type of wood will also affect the cost of the wood. Cedar is a less expensive wood than spruce or mahogany. Spruce is a more expensive wood than cedar, but it is less expensive than mahogany. Mahogany is the most expensive of the three woods.
Ultimately, the best way to choose an acoustic guitar top is to try out different guitars and see which one sounds and feels best to you. However, understanding the cost of the wood can help you narrow down your choices and find the perfect guitar for your needs.
FAQs about Cedar Guitar, Spruce, and Mahogany for Acoustic Guitar Tops
When choosing an acoustic guitar top, it’s important to consider the different types of wood available. Three of the most popular woods used for acoustic guitar tops are cedar, spruce, and mahogany. Each wood has its own unique sound, appearance, and feel.
Question 1: What are the tonal differences between cedar, spruce, and mahogany guitar tops?
Answer: Cedar produces a warm, mellow sound, while spruce produces a bright, crisp sound. Mahogany produces a rich, full sound.
Question 2: Which wood is the loudest?
Answer: Spruce is the loudest of the three woods, followed by mahogany and then cedar.
Question 3: Which wood has the most beautiful appearance?
Answer: This is a matter of personal preference, but many people find mahogany to be the most beautiful wood, followed by spruce and then cedar.
Question 4: Which wood is the most durable?
Answer: Mahogany is the most durable of the three woods, followed by spruce and then cedar.
Question 5: Which wood is the least expensive?
Answer: Cedar is the least expensive of the three woods, followed by spruce and then mahogany.
Question 6: Which wood is the best for a beginner?
Answer: Spruce is a good choice for beginners because it is a versatile wood that produces a balanced sound. However, any of the three woods can be a good choice for a beginner, depending on their personal preferences.
Ultimately, the best way to choose an acoustic guitar top is to try out different guitars and see which one sounds and feels best to you.
Summary of key takeaways:
- Cedar produces a warm, mellow sound, while spruce produces a bright, crisp sound. Mahogany produces a rich, full sound.
- Spruce is the loudest of the three woods, followed by mahogany and then cedar.
- Mahogany is the most durable of the three woods, followed by spruce and then cedar.
- Cedar is the least expensive of the three woods, followed by spruce and then mahogany.
Transition to the next article section:
Now that you know more about the different types of wood used for acoustic guitar tops, you can start shopping for the perfect guitar for your needs.
Tips for Choosing the Right Acoustic Guitar Top Wood
When choosing an acoustic guitar top wood, there are a few things to keep in mind:
Tip 1: Consider the sound you want. Cedar produces a warm, mellow sound, while spruce produces a bright, crisp sound. Mahogany produces a rich, full sound.
Tip 2: Consider the volume you need. Spruce is the loudest of the three woods, followed by mahogany and then cedar.
Tip 3: Consider the durability you need. Mahogany is the most durable of the three woods, followed by spruce and then cedar.
Tip 4: Consider the cost. Cedar is the least expensive of the three woods, followed by spruce and then mahogany.
Tip 5: Try out different guitars before you buy. This is the best way to find the guitar that sounds and feels best to you.
Summary of key takeaways:
- Consider the sound, volume, durability, cost, and feel of the guitar.
- Try out different guitars before you buy to find the one that’s right for you.
Transition to the article’s conclusion:
Choosing the right acoustic guitar top wood is an important decision. By following these tips, you can find the perfect guitar for your needs.
Conclusion
When choosing the right wood for your acoustic guitar top, there are several factors to consider, including the sound you want, the volume you need, the durability you need, the cost, and the feel of the guitar. By understanding the different types of wood available and their unique properties, you can make an informed decision about which wood is best for you.
Cedar, spruce, and mahogany are three of the most popular woods used for acoustic guitar tops. Cedar produces a warm, mellow sound, while spruce produces a bright, crisp sound. Mahogany produces a rich, full sound. Spruce is the loudest of the three woods, followed by mahogany and then cedar. Mahogany is the most durable of the three woods, followed by spruce and then cedar. Cedar is the least expensive of the three woods, followed by spruce and then mahogany.
Ultimately, the
best way to choose the right wood for your acoustic guitar top is to try out different guitars and see which one sounds and feels best to you. By following these tips, you can find the perfect guitar for your needs.
Youtube Video:
